This is a paid partner contribution. Commercial relationships are disclosed so readers can distinguish sponsored content from editorial guides.
A new roof is one of the larger things a household buys, and most people buy it only once or twice in a lifetime. That makes the contract an unfamiliar document. The price at the bottom draws the eye, yet the disagreements that sour a roofing job nearly always trace back to something the paper never mentioned: boards that turned out to be rotten, a vent nobody discussed, a flower bed full of nails. Five subjects cover most of that ground. Settling them before you sign costs an extra conversation or two, and it is far easier than settling them with the old shingles already in a trailer.
Before the five: is a replacement the right job?
It is worth pausing on the question that comes ahead of any contract. A full replacement makes sense when a roof is worn across the board: shingles curling or cracking in many places, granules piling up at the downspouts, storm damage on several slopes, or leaks that return however often they are patched. A roof with one cracked pipe boot or a handful of missing shingles is a repair, and a careful roofer will say so.
Ask whoever inspected to show you photographs of what led to the recommendation, slope by slope. If the evidence is a single trouble spot, ask whether a repair would carry the roof a few more seasons. Signing for a new roof should follow a clear answer to that question. If you have not yet had a proper look at the roof, that comes first, and the contract can wait until it is done.
One: the scope, line by line
Scope means exactly what will be removed, what will be installed and what will be left alone. A sound written estimate reads like a parts list, and it is reasonable to expect each of these to appear:
- The size of the roof in squares. One square is 100 square feet of roof surface, and the figure includes an allowance for waste from cutting.
- Tear-off of the existing roofing, how many layers are assumed, and disposal.
- Underlayment, the water-shedding layer between the decking and the shingles.
- Starter strip, ridge cap and drip edge, the pieces that finish the edges and peaks.
- Flashing at chimneys, walls and valleys, and whether it will be replaced or reused.
- Pipe boots and roof vents.
- The specific shingle line and color, written out by name.
- The permit, if your city requires one, and any items the building code calls for.
The item most often left vague is flashing. Reusing old metal is sometimes acceptable and sometimes a shortcut, and the estimate should say which is planned and where. A phrase such as "replace roof" with a single number beside it is a price, not a scope. Two bids can differ widely simply because one includes new flashing and drip edge and the other is silent.
Just as useful is a sentence about what the job does not cover. A roof replacement deals with the roof system. Ceiling stains from old leaks, attic insulation, gutters and exterior paint are separate work unless the estimate lists them. Knowing that in advance prevents the uncomfortable discovery that you and the roofer pictured different jobs.
Two: decking, the part nobody can see yet
Decking is the wood sheathing nailed to the rafters, the surface everything else is fastened to. Until the old roof comes off, nobody can see all of it. An inspector may notice hints, such as soft spots underfoot, a sag between rafters or stains visible from the attic, but the full picture appears only on the day of tear-off.
This is where an honest contract and a loose one part ways. An honest one admits the unknown and prices it ahead of time: damaged decking will be replaced at a stated price per sheet. A loose one says nothing, and the homeowner learns the price in the middle of the job with the house open to the sky, which is a poor moment to bargain.
Settle three things. What is the price per sheet if boards need replacing? Who decides a board is bad, and will you be shown photographs of it before it is covered? And is there a point at which the crew stops and calls you before going further? Nobody can promise how many sheets a roof will need. What can be promised is the price of each and the way you will be told.
Three: ventilation, the quiet half of the roof
An attic in a North Texas summer becomes extremely hot, and that heat works on shingles from underneath while the sun works on them from above. Ventilation is the roof's way of moving that air out. In most houses it works as a pair: air enters low, usually through vents under the eaves, and leaves high, through vents at or near the ridge. When either half is missing or blocked, the system stalls.
A replacement is the natural time to look at this, because the vents are coming off anyway. Ask what kind of exhaust vents are on the roof now, whether the plan keeps the same type or changes it, and why. Ask whether the intake vents at the eaves are clear, since insulation and paint often block them over the years. It is generally unwise to mix different kinds of exhaust vent on one roof, because they can pull air from each other and leave the lower attic stagnant.
Shingle manufacturers commonly make adequate ventilation a condition of their warranties, which is one more reason to see it addressed in writing.
Four: cleanup and protection of the property
Tearing off a roof drops a great deal of material around a house: old shingles, felt, and a large number of nails. Where it lands and who picks it up should be agreed before the first shingle is lifted.
Ask how the landscaping, air conditioning unit, windows and any pool will be shielded, where the trailer or container will sit, and whether the driveway will be blocked. Ask how nails are collected. Crews typically sweep the lawn, beds and driveway with a rolling magnet, and it is fair to ask that it be done more than once. Ask whether all debris leaves the same day. And ask who walks the property with you at the end.
Your side of the preparation matters too. Cars come out of the garage beforehand, patio furniture and potted plants move away from the walls, fragile items come off shelves and walls on the top floor, and pets and small children are best spent elsewhere for the day, since tear-off is loud. Our guide to arranging household life around a renovation has a fuller routine for days when the house belongs to a crew.
Five: the paperwork you keep
When the last truck leaves, what remains besides the roof is a folder. Decide what goes in it before you sign.
Warranties, in writing
There are normally two. The manufacturer's warranty covers the roofing product. The workmanship warranty comes from the installer and covers how it was put on. Ask for both in writing and read what each covers, for how long, and what would void it. A verbal assurance that the work is guaranteed is a kind sentiment and nothing more.
Permit, payment and proof
Ask your city whether a roofing permit is needed and confirm who will obtain it. Ask for proof of the contractor's insurance. Have the payment schedule spelled out, including what is due at signing and what is held until completion, and ask for written confirmation at the end that suppliers have been paid. Paying in full before any work begins is a mistake homeowners regret.
If insurance is paying for part of it
When hail or wind is behind the replacement, remember that the claim is yours. Check your policy for the deductible and the reporting deadline, and direct coverage questions to your insurer or agent. A roofer can document damage and be present when the adjuster visits. In Texas a contractor may not waive or absorb your deductible, so an offer to do so is a warning sign, not a favor.
A local yardstick for comparing bids
It helps to hold bids against a published description of what a complete job contains. A useful reference point is the page on roof replacement in Plano from Verde Roofing, a locally owned company, which lists what its written estimate shows: the squares, the materials, tear-off, underlayment and any code items, with damaged decking priced per sheet. Whichever companies you invite, a bid that cannot be matched to a list like that line for line is not ready to be compared.
When you lay two or three estimates side by side, resist ranking them by the bottom figure. Rewrite each one into the same order, scope, decking, ventilation, cleanup, paperwork, and mark the blanks. A lower price with three blanks is not cheaper yet. It is unfinished. Our explainer on reading home repair proposals in detail walks through that kind of comparison for any trade.
Mistakes that are easy to avoid
A few errors turn up again and again. One is choosing the shingle color from a small sample board indoors. Ask to see a full shingle outside, in sun and in shade, and look at a finished roof in that color if one is nearby. If your neighborhood has a homeowners association, read its guidelines and get approval in writing before materials are ordered.
A third is treating verbal promises as part of the deal. If the salesperson said the flashing would be new, the contract should say the flashing will be new. Anything that matters to you belongs on paper, however agreeable the conversation was.
When it is too soon to sign
There are moments when the right move is to wait. If you have only one estimate and no urgent leak, get another. If an insurance decision is pending, let it arrive before you commit to a scope. If the roofer cannot yet tell you the price per sheet of decking, the ventilation plan or the name of the shingle, the contract is not finished. And if water is coming in now, a temporary tarp buys the time to decide properly.
After the job, a final walk around the property, the warranties and the paid invoice complete the file. Our piece on wrapping up a home service visit describes what to confirm before the crew leaves. A roof installed under a clear agreement tends to be a quiet one, and a quiet roof is what you were buying.



